22 Best Etsy Gifts to Give Everyone in Your Life
Updated: Oct. 03, 2022Unusual finds, limited editions, and one-of-a-kind craftsmanship make these Etsy gifts some of the most thoughtful tokens of affection they'll ever receive.
Our editors and experts handpick every product we feature. We may earn a commission from your purchases.
One-of-a-kind Etsy gifts
If the people on your list are impossible to shop for because they already have everything they need, or you’re just looking for something extra special, you’re going to love this selection of limited-production Etsy gift ideas that simply can’t be found in big-box stores. While the site is known for its enormous selection of personalized gifts, creative gifts for her, and quirky gifts for men, arguably the best part of shopping at Etsy is knowing you’re supporting individual creators, artists, and small businesses. That means you can feel extra good about your purchase.
And that’s saying a lot since you’ll adore Etsy’s unique items, whether you’re searching for thoughtful gifts for Mom, hostess gifts, or gifts for best friends. You can also find the coolest Etsy baby gifts, wedding gifts, and Pinterest-worthy gifts for birthdays and holidays—for every budget and personal style. The only problem? You’re kind of going to want everything, including a few things for yourself, so consider yourself warned!
Austero Personalized Pizza Serving Board
Best for: Pizza lovers
This clever wooden serving board is one of the best Etsy gifts for the home chefs and pizza lovers on your list. A genius take on personalized gifts, it comes with six equal built-in pizza-shaped plates that are emblazoned with a name, date, or special word of choice.
Rynski Double Dog Sign
Best for: Pet parents
This artistic interpretation of two cartoon-like canines is the perfect gift for dog lovers who also love modern art. The metal-based lawn sign is hand-painted with vibrant colors to add a splash of whimsy next to the mailbox or in the garden. You’ll want to scoop this one up as soon as possible, though, because this artist’s unique designs tend to sell out.
Small Wonder Gifts Personalized “I Love You More” Mug
Best for: Your one and only
This adorable Etsy personalized gift is perfect for that special someone you love sharing your mornings with. Choose from 11- or 15-ounce sizes, and then simply type in the name you’d like on the mug. Give it on its own, or pair it with a few of these gifts for coffee lovers for a real pick-me-up.
Oakywood Charging Station
Best for: Apple devotees
This sleek, modern piece offers a major upgrade to typical iPhone and Apple Watch charging stations and is one of the most useful tech gifts you could possibly give. Choose from handmade oak or walnut finishes—both have thousands of five-star reviews.
Pegai Leather Tote Bag
Best for: Working moms
Need a gift for a mom who’s always on the go? This roomy genuine leather tote from Pegai gets our vote as a fantastic Etsy Mother’s Day gift because it’s stylish and she’ll use it every day. It comes in a variety of sizes, and you can personalize it with her initials. This handmade item comes from a small business that boasts many repeat customers.
The Cat Ball Great White Shark Cat Ball
Best for: Cat lovers
If the person on your list is kitty-obsessed (or shark-obsessed), this hysterically funny shark-themed cat cave is just the ticket. It’s one of the top-selling Etsy gifts in the cat bed category and an absolute conversation starter, thanks to its lifelike eyes and fins on its exterior, as well as the Instagram-worthy pics it’s sure to inspire.
Kelsey and CJ Custom Cartoon Couple Portrait
Best for: Lovebirds
Looking for a unique Etsy wedding gift or anniversary gift? You can’t go wrong with this custom illustration that will give the happy couple a dose of colorful cheer for their walls. Simply upload a photo of the couple, and the artist will go to work recreating them in cartoon-like form. You can even add a pet or child to the portrait, as well as choose color themes and sizes, for a thoughtful and unique gift they’ll treasure forever.
Leatherport Customized Lake Map
Best for: Outdoorsy types
This totally customizable leather-based map accented with rich hues is the perfect choice for guys who can’t get enough time out on the open water. If he grew up going to a local lake or just loves fishing on one now as an adult, you can feature that exact location. The Etsy artist will turn the locale into a museum-quality leather art print to hang on his wall. Each piece is handmade, and in addition to lakes, you can give the same treatment to rivers, beaches, and more. It makes a great gift for your brother or father-in-law, especially if he’s impossible to shop for.
Wilmot by Design Dad Fuel Insulated Coffee Cup
Best for: Dads, of course!
This way-too-accurate portable coffee mug will make any dad smile … and probably tell a classic dad joke or two. He’ll also love that it has a 20-ounce capacity and double-wall insulation that will keep his drink hot or cold for hours at a time.
Cre8ive Crayonz Space Crayons
Best for: Creative kids
Talk about an out-of-this-world gift idea for kids! Budding artists and astronauts will go gaga over these colorful crayons in the shape of planets, spaceships, and aliens, and parents will love that they provide hours of screen-free fun. Choose from boxes of six, nine, or 15 crayons, handmade from nontoxic, recycled materials you’ll all feel good about.
Ink and Shrink Swag Custom Mini Book Bookmark
Best for: Book lovers
Ringing in at just around $10, this custom bookmark is an affordable token of your affection. You can customize it with just about any book title you can think of, from classic books to punny children’s titles. It’s one of the most charming Etsy gifts for friends near and far—and so cute that you just might have to order one for yourself!
Personalized Name Puzzle
Best for: New parents
Looking for the perfect Etsy baby gift? You’ve found it! This wooden peg puzzle isn’t just a gift that will keep little ones engaged, entertained, and learning—the personalization also makes it a timeless keepsake. Choose the desired number of pegs and animals, as well as the baby’s name and an engraved message for the back. The all-wood construction makes it the kind of classic gift that never loses its appeal.
Amy Price Design Two-Tone Terrazzo Planter
Best for: Plant lovers
Grow something great in this practical and design-forward two-tone planter made by U.S.-based artisan Amy Price. You’ll feel good about putting money back into local economies and supporting a female-owned business. This eco-friendly and sustainable Etsy find also makes a thoughtful hostess gift when pre-planted with kitchen herbs.
True Warrior Jewelry Emerald-Diamond Shaped Hoops
Best for: Fashionistas
She’ll love wearing these funky modern earrings to hit the town or dress up an everyday look. It’s a particularly thoughtful gift for women born in May (emerald is the month’s birthstone), but it’s also a charming and fashionable choice for any accessories lover who appreciates a little pop of color.
Wood by Stu “There’s No Place Like Grandma & Grandpa’s House” Doormat
Best for: Grandparents
Truer words were never spoken. If you’re looking for a sweet gift for Grandma she’ll actually use, this customizable doormat is a total winner. Choose from sizes small to extra large to let the whole neighborhood know that your grandparents are the world’s best.
House of Harman Acrylic Door Sign
Best for: New homeowners
Anyone with a modern aesthetic will love this personalized acrylic door sign, which will give their home some serious curb appeal. Choose the font and backplate color, then add personalization like an address, number, or name. These signs make fabulous housewarming gifts, but they’re also a sophisticated choice for offices—and perfect for celebrating a new job or that big promotion to the corner office.
Love Talla The Love Fingerprint Necklace
Best for: Loved ones who have everything
It doesn’t get more personal than jewelry that has your loved one’s fingerprint engraved on its surface, and this Love Talla heart-shaped pendant necklace offers just that. Send in an image of your fingerprint, and the designer will get to work engraving it in gold-tone metal surrounded by sparkly cubic zirconia. It’s obviously one of the most unique Valentine’s Day gifts you’ll find, but it’s also a loving token of affection any time of year.
Cincha Travel Personalized Luggage Strap
Best for: Jet-setters
Be prepared for the frequent travelers in your life to freak out (in the best possible way) over this nifty little luggage strap. With a simple click, they’ll be able to secure their purse, duffel, or backpack to the top of their rolling luggage and free up their hands. It makes getting through airport security so much easier. Choose from a variety of neutral and fun shades and then add a monogram to personalize it.
Vegky Vegan Jerky Sampler
Best for: Vegetarians
Did you know that you can buy gourmet foods on Etsy? Well, you can, and this collection of mushroom-based jerky snacks will delight the vegetarians and vegans in your life. The five-pack includes mouthwatering flavors, including curry, pepper, spicy, wasabi, and their original formulation. They’re so delicious, filling, and fiber-filled, you’re going to want to order a few extra bags for yourself, even if you’re a carnivore.
Pet Party Co. Custom Face Photo Socks
Best for: Jokesters
Not sure what to give and don’t want to spend a fortune? These witty customizable face socks are sure to get a giggle. Choose from youth and adult sizes and add up to three faces, whether it’s your own, a favorite friend, or the family pet. Sure, it could be considered a gag gift, but it’s a functional gag gift they’ll end up wearing all the time!
Circle City Design Co. Personalized Cutting Board
Best for: Newlyweds
Give them this useful cutting board made of real wood, and they’ll be grateful. Engrave their name or special date into the board’s surface? Well, they’re going to love you forever. Choose from nearly a dozen sizes and wood finishes, and then be sure to ask for an invitation to the next charcuterie night.
Melan Threads Designs Hexagon Pink Rose Quartz Slice Coaster
Best for: Your favorite hosts
If you’re bringing a bottle of wine, consider adding a set of these gorgeous rose quartz coasters to set beneath the glasses. They’re a feminine, affordable touch that adds instant glamour to any table. If you’re buying for a holiday and want to create a more elaborate package, consider adding a few of these other gifts for wine lovers too.
Want more deals and product picks sent directly to your inbox? Sign up for the Stuff We Love newsletter!
