15 Best First Father’s Day Gifts for New Dads in 2023
Updated: May 23, 2023
Ideas for first Father's Day gifts the new dad will surely love.
Our editors and experts handpick every product we feature. We may earn a commission from your purchases.
Father’s Day is a celebration of all dads, no matter how many years you have been one or how many children you have. But for first-time fathers, the day feels even more special. Whether you’re shopping for your husband, brother, father, son or friend, get him one of these first Father’s Day gifts to make him smile.
Their lives just became all about diapers and bottles, so finding the perfect present will make these first-time dads feel extra special. Want more ideas for other dads in your life? Check out our complete Father’s Day gift guide.
When it comes to presents, it really is the thought that counts. Meaningful presents, like homemade gifts, are certainly one angle of gifting. Personalized presents are great for any father, such as a sweet picture of the newest addition to the family. Practical gifts also help him and mom adjust to their new lifestyle.
No matter your budget or who you’re shopping for, we have something to spoil him. Here are the best Father’s Day gift ideas that first-time dads will love.
For the napper: Bearaby Weighted Knit Blanket
Anything cozy to promote better sleep will make much-appreciated first Father’s Day gifts. This Bearaby weighted blanket improves sleep quality and relaxation through pressure stimulation. Crafted in cotton, the throw blanket is also incredibly soft and breathable if he wants to engage in skin-to-skin contact with the baby. He might be on the baby’s nap schedule, but this weighted blanket guarantees his naps will be restful, whether it’s 10 minutes or an hour.
For the one with a sweet tooth: Retro Candy Gift Box
Sugar cravers will love this giant box of candy and the sugar rush that comes with it during long and tired afternoons. Skittles, Ring-Pops, Baby Ruth, Laffy Taffy and York Peppermint Patty are just some of the 65 pieces of old-school candy in this retro candy box. He can enjoy it all himself or share it with his new dad friends at the park. This candy set would also make a great gift for Grandpa.
For the homebody: UGG Men’s Tasman Slipper
For the sleepless nights or while mom’s asleep, upgrade his house slippers to a quiet, comfy pair of UGGs. The wool lining gets warm in the winter and cool in summer to keep him comfortable all year long. The plush suede upper combines with a flexible outsole that is specifically made for indoor and outdoor use. He can easily slip these on with his comfy joggers to grab the mail or take the baby on a stroll through the neighborhood.
For the pizza-loving dad: Ooni Koda Pizza Oven
Dads deserve to be spoiled, too. He’ll celebrate best with a unique Father’s Day gift: an Ooni Koda pizza oven. Since it’s tougher for the new parents to go out on date nights, give him something to mix up his cooking routine. This outdoor pizza oven makes pies in a minute flat. It has an easy setup and lights with gas, so no coals necessary.
Dad can also use his Ooni pizza oven to cook steaks, vegetables and fish. For the next holiday, you can get him a pizza-themed gift basket with tools and fun ingredients.
For the runner: Hoka Clifton 9 Running Shoe
While he might not have time to hit a group class, there is certainly time for a quick run. This iconic Hoka running sneaker is lightweight, comfortable and flexible. Reflective details will help keep him safe in low-light situations, like dawn or dusk, when he might be squeezing in a few miles. A durable midsole with a rubble sole with traction works on any gravel as well as it does on a treadmill.
If you’re looking for another gift to pair with running sneakers, try a belt bag so he can keep his essentials safe and sound.
For the office dad: Wood Block Frame & Photo Print
Unfortunately, dads often return to work shortly after the baby is born. Make his work day a bit easier with an Artifact Uprising picture frame he can put on his desk to admire his new little boy or girl. This beautiful reclaimed pine frame will seamlessly match his office decor and complement the cute photo.
Personalized Father’s Day gifts are sentimental at any age, especially anything involving pictures of their children. It’s one of those first Father’s Day gifts he’ll cherish for years.
For the one who needs a caffeine boost: Coffee of the Month Subscription
His first year of being a dad will also be the year he and mom sleep the least. Make the adjustment easier by ensuring he’ll have fresh coffee waiting each morning. Bean Box is a coffee-of-the-month subscription box that will send him a bag of coffee from some of the best roasters.
This idea makes an excellent last-minute Father’s Day gift since the first delivery will arrive after the holiday. Write a cute message and stick it in a new mug for him to wake up to.
For the bearded dad: Deluxe Wet Shave Kit
No matter what style of beard the new daddy has, he will need to groom it and not let his look go astray. Upgrade his routine products with a Gentleman Jon shave kit to provide everything he needs for a clean shave. High-quality soap and luxe tools will make him feel like he is pampering himself daily during his shave routine. It’s one of those first Father’s Day gifts he’ll use again and again.
For the chill pops: Olukai Nohea Moku Shoes
Shoes make an excellent gift for any man in your life, so give him a pair of everyday Olukai sneakers to be his new go-to. With an anatomically contoured footbed, this sneaker will make his feet feel instantly comfortable and supported. No-tie laces and a stretchy upper are convenient and easy to slip on when running out the door for a quick formula or diaper run.
Plus, this is an all-weather sneaker with a rubber sole and traction to be both sunny and rainy day ready.
For the sipper: Whiskey Rocks Glass Set
He’s likely already swapping his household items to be more kid-friendly, so treat him with something he can enjoy after you put the baby to sleep. A set of whiskey glasses will bring him back to nights out on the town. The set of two comes with two ice ball molds, which means he can share a glass with his partner. Upgraded drinkware makes a great gift for a stepfather or father-in-law.
For the master chef: Le Creuset Traditional Braiser
If dad does all the cooking, treat him to a Le Creuset braiser. The wide base and lid allow for single-layer searing of meats and veggies for easy meals, even when dad is sleep deprived. The enameled cast iron helps distribute heat and cleans easily, which is great for busy parents. A meal shared with family tastes that much better.
Plus, certain colors are also on discount, making it one of the best Father’s Day sales of 2023.
For the gamer dad: Create Your Own Video Game Set
Any gamer father who might have lost hours of video-playing free time will enjoy this fun gift. This video game console allows you to customize your own video games and play retro arcade games. Between busy moments with the baby, he can learn how to code, keep his brain highly functional and have some old-school arcade fun. It can be used as a smartwatch with a pedometer when on the go.
Gamer enthusiasts and retro tech lovers will surely appreciate these 8-bit classic games.
For the jokester: Dad Jokes Pullover Sweatshirt
Graphic hoodies are easy and amusing gifts for a new dad. Any dad with a fun sense of humor will love this puny dad joke sweatshirt. It will get him straight on the path of telling dad jokes for years and years. The pullover sweatshirt is cozy and will fit right in with his relaxed and easy new dad uniform. Add a funny dad quote on his card to get him laughing.
For the mixologist: American Cocktail Club Subscription
Visiting bars with fancy cocktails probably won’t happen as frequently as it once did. So not bring the bar to him? Sign the dad up to receive a monthly cocktail subscription box. Inside, he’ll find premium ingredients to make cocktails by award-winning mixologists.
Each delivery contains four servings he can enjoy with his partner, friends or on particularly tough weeks, just himself. Subscription boxes make excellent first Father’s Day gifts or for any holiday because it’s easy for the giver and the receiver will love it.
For the handyman: Geekey Multi-Tool
Whether he’s putting together the crib or fixing things around the house, handy dads love to use their favorite tools. The Geekey multi-tool is a do-it-all gadget complete with screwdrivers, wrenches, a can and bottle opener and more. It’s stainless steel and hangs perfectly on a key ring. Make sure he’s prepared for any last-minute job whether he’s at home or on his first family vacation.
Stop hunting for the best products and deals—get our expert scoop on secret sales and discounts, gift ideas for everyone, and can’t-miss products. Sign up for the Stuff We Love newsletter.
